A pastor sits at his desk on a Friday afternoon. The Sunday homily is half-written. The hospital visits have piled up. There is a family in crisis he should be calling. His inbox has a question from the principal about an HVAC vendor quote, three from the DRE about sacramental prep scheduling, one from the music director about the Advent repertoire, and two from committee members about the capital campaign timeline. He will answer the pastoral ones first. The operational ones will sit. Some will become problems before he gets to them.
This is not a failure of the pastor. It is the predictable result of asking one person to be two different kinds of professional at once.
Catholic institutions are almost always led by someone who is a visionary and an expert on the mission - and specifically put in place for mission. The pastor is a trained spiritual leader, formed in seminary for years, ordained to provide sacraments and put in place to help lead a parish. The bishop is a successor to the apostles, carrying teaching and sanctifying and governing authority for a local church. The executive director of a foundation has usually spent a career in mission-driven work and brings deep understanding of what the foundation exists for. The principal of a Catholic school is almost always a formed educator with a particular vocation to children and families. The president of a ministry is typically its founder or its longest-serving mission-carrier.
All of these are the right people to be leading. None of them is usually also the operator who drives the day-to-day decisions that keep the institution moving, growing, and functioning effectively and efficiently.
That is a specific mismatch, and it is almost universal in Catholic institutional life.
The visionary leader is built for vision, mission fluency, teaching, pastoral presence, discernment, and representation of the institution to the people it serves. The operator is built for cadence, coordination, execution, decision-forcing, and the small continuous work of keeping an institution aligned across time. These are two different kinds of professional. Very few people are genuinely strong at both. Most people who try to be both end up doing neither as well as they could.
Most Catholic institutions respond to this mismatch in one of three inadequate ways.
The first: The business manager gets quietly elevated beyond her actual role. She is the most organized person in the building, so operational work drifts to her by default. She carries more and more of it over years, usually without the authority, the positioning, or the scope the work actually requires. She does the best she can. The institution gets some version of operational coordination, held together by one person's effort rather than by any defined role.
The second: The visionary leader carries the operational work personally. This works for a while - sometimes for years - because the leader is capable and committed. But it has a ceiling. Beyond a certain scale, the leader is either doing the operational work badly because he has no time, or doing the operational work well and the visionary work badly because the operational work has taken over his calendar. Either way, the institution starts drifting in whichever direction is loudest that week.
The third: Nobody at all. The ministry leaders, department heads, and staff each do their own thing. The leader is pulled in whichever direction is loudest. The institution operates as a federation of adjacent fiefdoms rather than as a coordinated organization. Things get done, but nothing is woven together, and the mission the leader articulated so clearly at the installation homily or the annual board meeting does not actually show up in the operational life of the institution.
What Catholic institutions need - almost universally - is the partner the visionary leader cannot be for himself. Someone whose job is operations, with the authority and the positioning to actually do it.
In corporate contexts this role has many names: Chief of staff, chief operating officer, director of operations, vice president of business operations. The specific title varies. The role is the same shape.
Here is what the role actually does.
1. Holds the operational cadence.
The weekly staff meeting agenda. The follow-up after decisions. The accountability for who owns what. The small, continuous, deliberately boring work of maintaining the rhythm that lets an institution move from direction to execution to result. The partner holds this cadence so the visionary leader doesn't have to.
2. Translates direction into execution.
The leader says "we need to focus on young families this year." The partner translates that into specific operational changes across formation, communications, liturgy, and youth ministry teams - what each team will actually do differently starting next month, what the success criteria will look like at ninety days, who owns which piece, and how progress gets reported. Without the translation, the vision stays an aspiration. With it, the vision becomes institutional work.
3. Coordinates across functions.
The handoffs between the business office, the DRE, the music director, the development director, the volunteer coordinator. The small operational connective tissue that lets the institution actually function as one organization rather than as adjacent silos. Most institutional pain lives in these handoffs, and most of it is fixable by someone whose job is specifically to watch them.
4. Surfaces decisions before they become crises.
The partner watches for the early signals. The budget line that is quietly running ahead of pace in September that will be a problem in December. The staff member who is quietly disengaging. The vendor whose service quality is slipping. The partner brings these to the leader with context and recommendations, so the leader can decide early, when the decision is still small, rather than late, when it has become a crisis.
The role is not glamorous. It is not visible. The person in it is rarely the face of the institution and does not want to be. What the role produces is the specific institutional health that lets the visionary leader stay in the work he is actually called to - and lets the institution grow without the leader becoming a bottleneck.
I have held some version of this role across much of the recent years of my career. Chief of Staff to a Vice President at Adobe for several years, where I was the operational partner to a leader whose own strengths were vision and client relationships and shaping the motivations and culture of our team. I was also COO at Exodus 90 for a stretch, where I was the operational partner to a founder-visionary whose own gifts were in spiritual formation and mission articulation. I know the role from the inside, and I know the specific nuance it requires: How to support a visionary leader without competing with him. How to drive decisions without dominating the room. How to be the operator without becoming the face. There is a specific posture to the role, and done well, it is one of the most consequential positions in any institution. Done well, the leader is more free to lead, and the institution moves faster, cleaner, and more sustainably than it could otherwise.
Three reasons this role does not get created in Catholic institutions:
The first is budget framing. The role looks like overhead on a budget line, not a productivity multiplier. Institutions that would cheerfully hire a second development director (because development directors bring in revenue) will not hire a chief of staff (because the ROI is harder to attribute, even though it is usually larger).
The second is a worry about layering. Leaders sometimes worry that creating this role will distance them from the work, or build an administrative layer that insulates them from the people they are called to serve. The worry is reasonable, and the right version of the role answers it rather than confirming it. The partner exists so the leader can be more present to the mission, not less.
The third is a quiet cultural resistance to anything that looks too corporate. Chief of staff feels like business language, and some leaders are uncomfortable bringing business language into pastoral work. This instinct is honorable - the Church is not a corporation, and the resistance comes from a desire to protect something real. The honest answer is that the operational discipline the role brings is what lets pastoral work actually scale. Naming the role in business language is not the same as making the institution a business.
The Catholic-specific version of this role has one more requirement worth naming. It is not purely operational. The partner to a visionary Catholic leader has to understand that the institution's work is mission-shaped, not margin-shaped. The operator who comes from a purely corporate background, and tries to apply purely corporate operational discipline to a parish or a diocese, will usually fail - because the metrics that would matter in a company (growth, efficiency, cost reduction, revenue per unit) are not quite the metrics that matter in a mission-driven institution serving souls. The partner has to be fluent in both languages: Corporate operational discipline and Catholic institutional life. That specific hybrid is uncommon. But it exists, and the institutions that find this partner compound a specific kind of health over years.
This pattern is not unique to Catholic institutions. Any small or mid-sized mission-driven organization led by a visionary founder lives inside the same dynamic. The nonprofit whose executive director is a brilliant program leader but is also trying to run the operations. The foundation whose president carries mission vision deeply but spends half his week on operational coordination that someone else should own. The family-held business whose founder has never quite handed off the operational reins. The pattern is universal; the Catholic institutional version has its specific texture, but the underlying mismatch is everywhere.
This is stewardship. Of the leader - whose vocation is to lead, not to spend his week on vendor quotes and scheduling conflicts. Of the mission - which does not get executed on the strength of vision alone. Of the team and the people the institution serves - who deserve an organization that actually functions as one body, not a collection of unaligned parts. And of the operator herself, when she exists - because she deserves to be hired into a real role with real authority, not quietly elevated into a shape nobody ever named.
The institutions that find this partner, define the role, and empower it to do the work - those institutions are almost always the ones where the vision actually happens in the world.
What is missing, almost universally, is not the vision. The vision is clear. What is missing is the operator who turns vision into institutional reality - and the institutional decision to name the role and hire for it.
In fieri. Ad alta.
-Michael
Deacon Michael Halbrook
One note at the end: I'm rethinking the shape and cadence of this Weekly. After a few months of new-era essays, I want to be honest that weekly may not actually be the right rhythm going forward. Next week may be quiet. The cadence may shift to every other week, or to something else. The essays and the thinking continue - the frequency is what I'm working out. I'll let you know when I've landed it.
If you want to see where your institution actually sits across mission, technology, and organizational effectiveness, Where You Stand is a free fifteen-question diagnostic. adaltaleadership.com/diagnostic
If your institution has a visionary leader doing work that is not quite his gift - and you're starting to see the cost - an Hour with Michael is a focused way to think through what the partner role could look like for you. adaltaleadership.com/hour
Know a leader at an organization - a parish, diocese, foundation, Catholic school, or another Catholic organization - who should read this? Forward it to them.
Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.